One-Minute Book Reviews

August 3, 2009

Clara Kramer’s ‘Clara’s War: One Girl’s Story of Survival’ – A Teenager’s Holocaust

Filed under: Biography,Memoirs — 1minutebookreviewswordpresscom @ 3:25 pm
Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

A first-person account of hiding in a bunker during the Nazi occupation of Poland

Clara’s War: One Girl’s Story of Survival. By Clara Kramer. With Stephen Glantz. Harper/Ecco, 339 pp., $25.99.

By Janice Harayda

Clara Kramer tells us early in this book that when Nazis arrested Jewish leaders in her town in Poland in 1941, her mother donated “her wedding band” to help ransom them. More than 150 pages later, she says that her family had to pay a monthly fee to the Christians who were hiding them in a bunker, and when her parents ran out of money in 1944, her mother gave “her wedding ring”: “We didn’t sell it until now.”

This first quote comes from the story told in Clara’s War with the aid of screenwriter Stephen Glantz. The second comes from one of its excerpts from the teenage diary said to have inspired the narrative. The inconsistency between the two quotes – one of a number involving substantive facts – shows a problem with this book: Its publisher bills it as a “biography,” but it reads more like a novelization of a life.

As Clara’s War has it, five thousand Jews lived in Zolkiew, Poland, at the start of World War II, and about 50 survived. Clara Kramer was one of the lucky ones. She survived the Holocaust because an ethnic German named Valentin Beck hid her family and others for more than a year in a bunker under his house, “a space no larger than a horse stall.” Beck had a reputation as an anti-Semite, a drunk and a philanderer, and he appears to have had complex reasons, not all of them noble, for sheltering Jews during the Nazi occupation of Zolkiew. He often summoned one of the women in the bunker to his living quarters for trysts, and the affair may have begun before she arrived. His infidelity enraged his wife and, when it came to light, imperiled everyone under his roof.

If Clara’s War is accurate, the Becks were nonethess heroic, saving 18 Jews, and have been honored by Yad Vashem, Israel’s official Holocaust memorial. Valentin’s acts of kindness included bringing the teenage Clara composition books and a blue pencil that she used to keep a diary, now in the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum.

But it is hard to know how accurate the book is. With Glantz’s help, Kramer describes many scenes in a detail few people could recall even with the help of a diary, such as line-by-line conversations complete with gestures and facial expressions. Some events serve literary purposes that seem too neat. One occurs in the prologue when the author is 12 years old and her sister leaves the shelter of an apple tree to look at bombers overhead – a foreshadowing of a disaster that will occur later. You never really see how 18 people could have survived in a crypt-like space the size of “a horse stall,” though the book has a diagram and says that the bunker still exists and the author and others have returned to it.

Kramer kept in touch with others saved by the Becks, and they and their descendants presumably have confirmed much of the story in Clara’s War. Even so, you wish the book had fewer inconsistencies and cinematic flourishes. The excerpts from the diary in the Holocaust Museum are fascinating in their own right, and you hope that readers someday will have a chance to read the entire journal in straight-up form.

Best line: “My father, like every Jewish business owner in town, had his business confiscated by the Nazis. We had to wear the white armband with the blue Jewish star above the right elbow. Any offense was punishable by death. The day the order for the armbands came down, none of us could leave the house until my mother had embroidered them. It took Mama over two hours to do one armband.”

Worst line: “My father’s family was so religious that they had had considered it irrelevant to have their weddings recorded by the state. So even though we went by the name of Schwartz in our day-to-day life, all of our official papers, including my birth certificate, bore the name of Gottlieb.” Why Gottlieb? Was Gottlieb carried over from previous generations not mentioned in the book? Or did ultra-religious Jews choose it because it means “God love”?

Published: 2009 (first American edition), 2008 (British edition from Ebury Press, part of Random House).

Watch a video of Clara Kramer talking about the Holocaust and her book.

Consider reading instead of or in addition to Clara’s War: All But My Life, a beautifully written memoir by Gerda Weissmann Klein and a pillar of Holocaust literature.

Furthermore: Kramer lives in Elizabeth, NJ. She helped found the Holocaust Resource Center at Kean University in Union, NJ. Glantz is a screenwriter. The inconsistencies cited in the first paragraph of this review appear on pages 43 and 219 of the book and can be confirmed by using the “Browse Inside” tool on the HarperCollins Web site to search for “her wedding band” and “her wedding ring.”

© Janice Harayda. All rights reserved.


  1. There have been so many of these ‘memoirs’ from supposed Holocaust survivors lately, at least two now proven to be completely false you really have to wonder.

    Comment by Digital Dame — August 7, 2009 @ 2:53 pm | Reply

    • You do have to wonder. You’d think that editors would be hyper-vigilant about things like glaring inconsistencies after the sort of problems you’ve mentioned, but I don’t see it happening.

      Comment by 1minutebookreviewswordpresscom — August 7, 2009 @ 10:09 pm | Reply

  2. After reading this book and seeing the picture inserts which include pictures of her family, the Becks, and the house where the story took pace including the trap door and bunker, there is no doubt in my mind that this story is not fabricated. A reason for some of the inconsistencies could be the age of the woman. Though she did have her actual diary to help with many details I’m sure her memory of the events isn’t perfect. As for the lines about the wedding rings… perhaps she could have meant engagement ring? Most women in my family have two rings, a wedding band and a ring with a stone. Just a thought.

    Comment by xrowanbraex — August 28, 2009 @ 12:29 am | Reply

    • Some of the inconsistencies may well result from the author’s age. But that does not excuse them, because another writer and an editor were involved. At the very least, Clara’s War reflects lapses on the part of the editor who allowed the inconsistencies to stand.

      Memoirists have given Americans much reason to be skeptical of books that describe events that occurred long ago in as much detail as this one does. Given the recent scandals here involving memoirs exposed as embellished or faked, publishers to make every effort to avoid raising flags for readers of the books they support. And the publishers of this one — both in the U.S. and the U.K. — don’t seem to me to have done that.

      Comment by 1minutebookreviewswordpresscom — September 1, 2009 @ 11:43 pm | Reply

  3. This inconsistency – if it is indeed an inconsistency – is so trivial compared to the wonderful story that is told in this book. Almost any large scale work, like a novel or film, is bound to have small flaws. This means nothing next to the story being told. It is a thrilling and moving narrative, well-written and inspiring. We will never forget.

    Comment by John Ginsburg — December 13, 2015 @ 4:01 pm | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: